Tomlinson Law PA
Tomlinson Law PA
  • Home
  • Alc Bev Law 101
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • More
    • Home
    • Alc Bev Law 101
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
  • Home
  • Alc Bev Law 101
  • About Us
  • Contact Us

Alcohol Beverage Trade Practice Law Overview

Introduction

The laws that regulate alcohol beverages are unique. As a product of Prohibition and the puritanical attitudes in the US toward alcohol, our industry is heavily regulated.  This summary provides a broad overview of the alcohol beverage trade practice laws and the regulatory framework that enforces them.

Who Regulates?

All alcohol suppliers and wholesalers have to comply with strict regulatory controls from at least three sources:

  • Federally, through the Alcohol and Tobacco Tax and Trade Bureau (TTB);
  • At the state level, through alcohol beverage control (ABC) authorities; and
  • Locally, through local alcohol boards and police authorities.


Even though TTB does not have jurisdiction over retailers, state ABC and local boards heavily regulate what retailers legally can and cannot do.

Why Do Alcohol Laws Matter?

Whether small or large, a company must take its reputation very seriously and all companies are under constant scrutiny of their actions by regulators and competitor suppliers and wholesalers. Violating the alcohol laws can put retailers’, wholesalers’ or suppliers’ licenses in jeopardy, potentially forcing businesses to shut down; subject companies and employees to fines and penalties (sometimes in the millions of dollars); and/or, in extreme cases, result in criminal punishment. 

What Do The Alcohol Laws Target?

The alcohol beverage trade practice laws primarily focus on prohibiting suppliers and wholesalers from providing “inducements” to retailers. Grounded in Prohibition era concerns, these trade practice laws prohibit suppliers from, for example, paying slotting fees, running sales incentives, or providing equipment, gifts, or other “things of value” to retailers.


For TTB to find a violation of the trade practices laws, it generally must show (1) that competitive products were excluded due to the trade practices activity, and (2) that retailer independence was threatened. State ABC authorities, which regulate all three tiers, usually only have to show that the supplier or wholesaler offered and/or the retailer received an unlawful “thing of value” in order to find a violation.  

Important Trade Practice Topics

Slotting Allowances

Retailer Incentives, Gifts, and Payments

Retailer Incentives, Gifts, and Payments

Payments from a supplier or wholesaler to a retailer for the rental or purchase of shelf, display, back bar, drink well, storage or warehouse space is a per se (i.e., in and of itself, without the need for authorities to demonstrate any anti-competitive consequence) violation of federal law and the laws of most states. The TTB has a broad interpretation of slotting allowances.

Retailer Incentives, Gifts, and Payments

Retailer Incentives, Gifts, and Payments

Retailer Incentives, Gifts, and Payments

Federal law and state laws prohibit a supplier or wholesaler from giving money, goods, tickets, trips/travel, etc. to a retailer or its em­ployees, regardless if such items are given in connection with meeting performance objectives, connected to bartender/server contests, or to participate in or sponsor a retailer’s conference/sales meeting.

Control of Pricing and Purchasing

Retailer Incentives, Gifts, and Payments

Control of Pricing and Purchasing

A supplier, wholesaler, or retailer cannot control the purchasing or pricing decisions of other licensees; all pricing decisions are the sole discretion of the actual selling party. Other prohibited practices include consignment sales and a supplier or wholesaler issuing any pricing credits to retailers.

Entertainment of Retail Licensees

Advertising and Other Things of Value to Retailers

Control of Pricing and Purchasing

Typically, a supplier or wholesaler may provide a retailer with reasonable business entertainment, however, paying for airfare and lodging expenses is strictly prohibited in all instances.  Also, many states specifically outline the types and costs of permissible entertainment.

Advertising and Other Things of Value to Retailers

Advertising and Other Things of Value to Retailers

Advertising and Other Things of Value to Retailers

Items that have value to a retailer only as advertising are generally permissible, subject to per item and/or aggregate cost limitations in some states. Items that have any utilitarian value to a retailer, including glassware and equipment, must be sold to a retailer for no less than their initial purchase price.

Product Displays

Advertising and Other Things of Value to Retailers

Advertising and Other Things of Value to Retailers

A supplier or wholesaler may provide retailers with product displays that are conspicuously branded and designed to hold alcohol products. Federal laws restrict such items to no more than $300 per brand, but state regulations often vary on this amount.

Cooperative Advertising

Samples and Product Withdrawals

Cooperative Advertising

Cooperative advertising, whereby a supplier or wholesaler participates with a retailer in paying for advertising placed by a retailer, is prohibited under federal regulations and the laws of most states. Also, many states prohibit a supplier or wholesaler from including in their own advertising references to a retailer. However, certain s

Cooperative advertising, whereby a supplier or wholesaler participates with a retailer in paying for advertising placed by a retailer, is prohibited under federal regulations and the laws of most states. Also, many states prohibit a supplier or wholesaler from including in their own advertising references to a retailer. However, certain states permit the mention of two or more unaffiliated retail licensees in order to inform consumers of product availability. 

Consumer Refunds

Samples and Product Withdrawals

Cooperative Advertising

Instant redeemable coupons and/or mail-in refund offers on alcohol beverage products and on non-alcoholic, cross-promotional items are permitted in a number of states. However, laws require that all retailers are treated equally so that a particular coupon offer or its equivalent must be available to all in-state retailers.

Samples and Product Withdrawals

Samples and Product Withdrawals

Samples and Product Withdrawals

Generally, furnishing free alcohol to retailers is prohibited. However, states may have exceptions allowing for limited quantities of samples to retailers who have not previously purchased the item.

Drink Menus

Third Party Activities

Samples and Product Withdrawals

A supplier or wholesaler may pay the reasonable costs of printing the pro-rated portion of a retailer’s drink menu, which cannot include food items or menu jackets.  All payments require a detailed invoice and must go directly to a bona fide printing company that is independent of the retailer.

Third Party Activities

Third Party Activities

Third Party Activities

Federal and state laws may not be circumvented by requesting or re­quiring a wholesaler, agency, printing company, radio station, or other third party to do anything that a supplier, wholesaler, or their respective employees may not do directly.

Records

Third Party Activities

Third Party Activities

It is critical that industry members maintain complete, truthful, and accurate records of product samples, display activities, and promotional programs. State and federal regulators are able to request copies of such records without prior notice.

Tomlinson Law PA

Fort Lauderdale, FL

(615) 268-2350 | trey@tomlinson.law

© 2022 Tomlinson Law PA - All Rights Reserved.

Attorney advertising. Information on this page is not intended to provide legal advice.

This website uses cookies.

We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.

Accept